Michael H
VerifiedJune 19, 2021 Stayed at: PERCH-1, Loop: Whitefish Lake
I took my 10 and 14 year old boys to Sylvania for a 3 night trip. This was the introduction to canoe camping for the younger boy, as I plan on taking him along on a BWCA trip next year.
Sylvania is similar to BWCA, but there are some significant differences. The main one for me is the distance from the water to the fire grate. In BWCA, it is like 20 yards, but in Sylvania, it is closer 50 yards. I don't like being so far from the water... you can't see the beautiful sunrise/sunset. Also, there is no open ground near the shoreline, so if your gear gets wet (like ours did), nothing drys out because no sun or breeze reaches the camp.
The positive difference is the the portages are much easier... flatter, wider, and less elevation change.
The similarity is the fishing is fantastic at both.
Overall, it was a great experience, but I'll stick to the BWCA.
Helpful