Reviews (5)
What Guests Are Saying
Sunset Bay Vacation Resort offers a community atmosphere with friendly staff and numerous enjoyable events. While some owners may be perceived as rude and there are concerns about rising fees and favoritism, many visitors appreciate the welcoming environment and great dock space. Overall, the resort has a supportive community vibe, despite some negative experiences reported by a few.
What Guests Are Saying
Sunset Bay Vacation Resort offers a community atmosphere with friendly staff and numerous enjoyable events. While some owners may be perceived as rude and there are concerns about rising fees and favoritism, many visitors appreciate the welcoming environment and great dock space. Overall, the resort has a supportive community vibe, despite some negative experiences reported by a few.
Review Summary
Edward Krawiecki
July 12, 2025
This is a community for trailers to be set on their own site. Annual lot fees include water, sewer and park maintenance and amenities
Mitch Neary
June 8, 2025
Owners are rude , prices go up yearly . Many other places on the lake for much cheaper . Same bands over and over . Favoritism between owners and some renters, Rules only apply to people that they want them to. Campers are very close to each other. I had a camper threat in my life last year. The owners wouldn’t tell me their name so I can contact police.
Tom P
June 2, 2025
Band played here, but the weather was quite chilly and damp for a late May night. Some enthusiastic folks showed up and we had fun.
Our POC Brian was pleasant and happy to help, and we hope to be back playing again soon when it's warmer.
mike shining
December 12, 2024
It's the best! Everyone so friendly. Campers, staff, workers.
Lots of events for everyone to enjoy. Dock space is great and protected by its beautiful bay. Come join the family and wonderful campers and staff!
Teena Ryan
August 1, 2020
Sunset bay was a great place for us for 4 years we tolerated management changes and rules changing with each manager. One more confrontational than the next. We stayed out of the way. We came to sunset bay with 4 separate families. We have vacationed together for 20 years this was ideal for us. Our children were grown and we all looked forward to retirement together at the lake. We had a beautiful clean site and were never spoken to for breaking rules.
During a management change our deposit was misplaced. Recurring managers sent us an eviction notice with 30 days to vacate before the season started this was March . We were shocked and offered to drive directly to campground to pay in full before season started. We were told absolutely not and in Glens words we dont want your kind here. We were heartbroken. But had felt we had no recourse. So we sold our camp. At the time of sale we were told that we are banned for life from entering the campground to visit our family and friends. This was in 2018. Last year we asked permission to come visit for ring of fire. We were there for 2 hours. I found out recently that the groundskeeper saw us and reported it to the owners who we have never met. And we are again banned for life. I know you are thinking theres more to the story. Theres not. We spent alot of money to be there and in the end treated horribly. This year it continues. We moved on but miss our friends. Very sad and confusing. I have had people urge us to fight this as we did nothing to be banned for life. I know the owners have heard this story but curious to know what was really said. Sunset Bay feel free to reach out to us to remedy this. You have a great campground that could be amazing with decent people running it. No one should ever be treated as we were and continue to be over a missing 600.00 check.
Location Sunset Bay Vacation Resort
Address:
353 Paradise Point Road
Mayfield, NY, 12117
United States
The campground is on Paradise Point Road. New York State Route 30 is near and New York State Route 29 is near.
Latitude & Longitude: 43.1282 / -74.2398
Elevation: 258 feet