Anthony B
VerifiedNovember 7, 2022 Stayed at: CABIN, Loop: HORSETHIEF
The Cabin was Perfect
Helpful
Help us improve by reporting any incorrect amenity information for Horsethief Cabin.
19 reviews
Horsethief Cabin, located 30.8 mi on an unpaved road, offers a beautiful and rustic getaway near Horsethief Lake, ideal for fishing. The cabin is in good condition, with adequate cooking supplies, though it could use more plates and silverware. While some guests noted cleanliness issues and the need to manually fill the toilet tank, the overall experience was positive, with no issues reported regarding mice or pests during their stay.
Based on guest feedback
3.6
Based on 19 reviews
Showing 19 reviews
November 7, 2022 Stayed at: CABIN, Loop: HORSETHIEF
The Cabin was Perfect
Helpful
July 30, 2022 Stayed at: CABIN, Loop: HORSETHIEF
My daughter and I took my wife for her birthday on 7-22-24, We were looking forward for a nice relaxing weekend at the Horsethief cabin to celebrate my wife's birthday, but what a disappointment that was.
First time writing a review, but I feel it is necessary to tell the condition of the cabin and maybe create an awareness, so everyone can contribute to take care of it for future tenants.
USFS mentioned in their web site that they don't provide maid service and the tenants are to clean after themselves before to leave the property, but I think that doesn't mean the rangers should not stop by now and then to check on the condition of the property before someone else's arrival.
Horse cabin will take you out of your comfort zone as it is if we don't take care of it. The mouse infestation is not a joke, we arrived at the cabin and first thing we see are rodents climbing all over the countertop, silver ware let on the sink, appliances, etc. The smell of the house was hideous, food left in the garbage can from who knows how long ago, microwave popcorn inside it, cobwebs everywhere and a mop that had created mold, box spring eaten on the side and rats nesting inside. We cleaned the house with Clorox, bleach, Lysol, etc, some of the products where at the cabin.
Getting dark, so we turned on the lights on and left the door open to refresh the house and prepare something to eat, 100s of mosquitoes had gotten inside and was almost impossible to eat. We covered the mattress with 2 covers and a sleeping bag because of the smell and covered our heads because mosquitos were everywhere. Every time we returned to the cabin, we could see mice droppings all over, so we cleaned some more to be able to use the place.
Always complain about how many things my wife brings in for camping, this time, totally worth it. She was not happy and I sure I'll be hearing this for a long, long time.
Hopefully you'll have a better story to tell and a much happier wife.
PS: Gorgeous Scenery
Helpful
July 30, 2022 Stayed at: CABIN, Loop: HORSETHIEF
My daughter and I took my wife for her birthday on 7-22-24, We were looking forward for a nice relaxing weekend at the Horsethief cabin to celebrate my wife's birthday, but what a disappointment that was.
First time writing a review, but I feel it is necessary to tell the condition of the cabin and maybe create an awareness, so everyone can contribute to take care of it for future tenants.
USFS mentioned in their web site that they don't provide maid service and the tenants are to clean after themselves before to leave the property, but I think that doesn't mean the rangers should not stop by now and then to check on the condition of the property before someone else's arrival.
Horse cabin will take you out of your comfort zone as it is if we don't take care of it. The mouse infestation is not a joke, we arrived at the cabin and first thing we see are rodents climbing all over the countertop, silver ware let on the sink, appliances, etc. The smell of the house was hideous, food left in the garbage can from who knows how long ago, microwave popcorn inside it, cobwebs everywhere and a mop that had created mold, box spring eaten on the side and rats nesting inside. We cleaned the house with Clorox, bleach, Lysol, etc, some of the products where at the cabin.
Getting dark, so we turned on the lights on and left the door open to refresh the house and prepare something to eat, 100s of mosquitoes had gotten inside and was almost impossible to eat. We covered the mattress with 2 covers and a sleeping bag because of the smell and covered our heads because mosquitos were everywhere. Every time we returned to the cabin, we could see mice droppings all over, so we cleaned some more to be able to use the place.
Always complain about how many things my wife brings in for camping, this time, totally worth it. She was not happy and I sure I'll be hearing this for a long, long time.
Hopefully you'll have a better story to tell and a much happier wife.
PS: Gorgeous Scenery
Helpful
June 21, 2022 Stayed at: CABIN, Loop: HORSETHIEF
It seemed this cabin had not been used in awhile. There were cob webs everywhere. There was no way to keep windows up we had to use serving utensils. There is a definite mouse problem. They came out at night. Keep all food and garbage secure. Scared the grandkids on the futon. They did not want to sleep there again. The main bedroom also showed signs of them eating away at box springs for nesting though we never saw them in the bedroom. Empty traps are left for you to set up which we did. Never caught one. Caught a very nice ranger who said they are aware and set trap under house as well. He said he would try to take care of webs etc. the kids overall had a great time exploring the lake and around camp
Helpful
June 21, 2022 Stayed at: CABIN, Loop: HORSETHIEF
It seemed this cabin had not been used in awhile. There were cob webs everywhere. There was no way to keep windows up we had to use serving utensils. There is a definite mouse problem. They came out at night. Keep all food and garbage secure. Scared the grandkids on the futon. They did not want to sleep there again. The main bedroom also showed signs of them eating away at box springs for nesting though we never saw them in the bedroom. Empty traps are left for you to set up which we did. Never caught one. Caught a very nice ranger who said they are aware and set trap under house as well. He said he would try to take care of webs etc. the kids overall had a great time exploring the lake and around camp
Helpful
December 30, 2021 Stayed at: CABIN, Loop: HORSETHIEF
Great location. A bit hard to get to, yet worth it. Could do without all the ORV's driving by as well.
Accommodations were nice for our family of six. Cabin could use more utensils-make sure you bring some. Next time, we'll bring extras to leave for the next visitors.
Helpful
December 30, 2021 Stayed at: CABIN, Loop: HORSETHIEF
Great location. A bit hard to get to, yet worth it. Could do without all the ORV's driving by as well.
Accommodations were nice for our family of six. Cabin could use more utensils-make sure you bring some. Next time, we'll bring extras to leave for the next visitors.
Helpful
January 15, 2020 Stayed at: CABIN, Loop: HORSETHIEF
Another wonderful stay!! My fiancé and two daughters and I fit comfortably and the location is IDEAL. I can’t recommend it enough.
Helpful
January 15, 2020 Stayed at: CABIN, Loop: HORSETHIEF
Another wonderful stay!! My fiancé and two daughters and I fit comfortably and the location is IDEAL. I can’t recommend it enough.
Helpful
Prescott National Forest, Prescott, AZ 86303 United States
Elevation: 1,832 ft
From Phoenix, Arizona: When traveling Northbound on I-17 take the Bumble Bee Exit 248 and continue North on the dirt road, taking Forest Road (FR) 259 to Crown King. From Crown King, take (FR) 259A south for 0.5 mi to the junction of 52. Take FR 5...
From Phoenix, Arizona: When traveling Northbound on I-17 take the Bumble Bee Exit 248 and continue North on the dirt road, taking Forest Road (FR) 259 to Crown King. From Crown King, take (FR) 259A south for 0.5 mi to the junction of 52. Take FR 52 southeast for about 5 mi to the Horse Thief Basin Recreation Area. The cabin sits adjacent to the Horse Thief Lake Rd.
Alternate route from Flagstaff, Arizona: Traveling Southbound on I-17 take Exit 263, turn right and proceed towards a roundabout and merge onto Hwy 69 North towards Prescott for 2.4 mi until turning left on to Spring Ln. in Spring Valley. Continue down Spring Ln. for 0.7 mi until you get to Duffers Dr. turn right onto Duffers Dr. The road will become unpaved, continue to travel for 1.4 mi until you get to the intersection of Duffers Dr. and S. Antelope Creek Rd. and turn left and drive for 23 mi until arriving to Crown King, Arizona. From Crown King, take (Forest Rd) 259A south for 0.5 mi to a junction with 52. Take FR 52 southeast for about 5 mi to the Horse Thief Basin Recreation Area.The cabin sits adjacent to the Horse Thief Lake Rd.
From Prescott, Arizona: From Downtown Prescott travel South on State Route 69 for 31 mi until you arive to Spring Valley, Arizona and turn right onto Spring Ln. Continue down Spring Ln. for 0.7 mi until you get to Duffers Dr. turn right onto Duffers Dr. The road will become unpaved at this point, continue to travel for 1.4 mi until you get to the intersection of Duffers Dr. and S. Antelope Creek Rd. and turn left and drive for 23 mi until arriving to Crown King, Arizona From Crown King, take 259A south for 0.5 mi to a junction with 52. Take FR 52 southeast for about 5 mi to the Horse Thief Basin Recreation Area. The cabin sits adjacent to the Horse Thief Lake Rd.
Check in time
2PM
Check out time
12PM
Last updated: October 22, 2026